Visibility check: Company A, Sanford, FL
This is a real check of a local service business, with its name and every competitor's name taken out. Nothing else is changed. Every check follows the same steps whatever the business. A restaurant gets the questions diners ask, a salon the questions clients ask. Yours comes with your names left in and a screenshot of every answer.
You were named in
For your home town, ChatGPT named you in both answers. For Sanford, the bigger market next door, one Google AI Mode answer named you, to the question about green pools. ChatGPT and Perplexity never did.
| Assistant | Answers | Named you |
|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | 6 | 0 |
| Google AI Mode | 6 | 1 |
| Perplexity | 3 | 0 |
| Sanford total | 15 | 1 |
| Home town, ChatGPT | 2 | 2 |
Where you stand, everywhere customers look
| Area | What I found | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Website | Three pages, one town named, no prices, no page descriptions for Google, no business details in the code. | Needs work |
| Google profile | 4.6 stars and more reviews than the three most-named competitors, but under a different version of the business name than the website. | Good base |
| Listings | On Yelp, Nextdoor and the BBB (accredited). Not on Thumbtack or Angi, which two assistants cited for competitors. | Gaps |
| Reviews | Plenty of them, a solid rating. No simple way for happy customers to leave a new one. | Strong |
| AI answers | Named in 1 of 15 answers for the bigger town next door. | Weak |
The companies the assistants picked
| Company | Named in | Google rating | Reviews | What they have that you don't |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Competitor 1 | 7 of 15 | 5.0 | 43 | Prices on its website, cited by Perplexity |
| Competitor 2 | 7 of 15 | 4.5 | 15 | Thumbtack and Angi profiles |
| Competitor 3 | 5 of 15 | 4.8 | 68 | All 5 mentions in Google AI Mode, which drew on Google profiles |
| Competitor 4 | 4 of 15 | – | – | BBB A+ profile |
| Competitor 5 | 4 of 15 | 5.0 | 5 | Monthly plans and prices on its website |
| You | 1 of 15 | 4.6 | more than #1–3 | BBB accreditation, Yelp, Nextdoor |
Findings and fixes
-
Your website names one town
The site only mentions your home town. The assistants name you there, and almost never for Sanford, even though you're next door.
FixAdd a service-area section, and a short page for Sanford and each other town you serve. -
Three versions of your name
Google uses one version of your business name, your website another, and the state register and BBB a third. Assistants match a business across sites by its name.
FixPick one name and use it everywhere: Google, website, BBB, Yelp and every new listing. -
A three-page website
Three pages and no description for search results. There's no page an assistant can match to “weekly pool cleaning” or “green pool”.
FixAdd pages for weekly service, green pool cleanup and equipment repair, each with a page description. -
No business schema, no prices
Search engines have to guess your area, hours and services. With no prices, “affordable” and “how much” questions quote competitors.
FixAdd LocalBusiness schema (name, address, phone, hours, towns served) and a starting price for weekly service. -
Missing from Thumbtack and Angi
Good: you're BBB accredited and on Yelp and Nextdoor. But answers that named Competitor 2 cited Angi (ChatGPT) and Thumbtack (Google AI Mode).
FixCreate free Thumbtack and Angi profiles with the same name, phone and address as your Google profile. Both will offer paid lead plans. You don’t need them for this. -
No easy way to leave a review
Your rating is good, but new reviews come in slowly. Recent reviews are one of the things Google and the assistants weigh.
FixA short review link and a two-line text to send after each job, plus replies to the reviews you already have.
All 15 Sanford answers
Each answer was recorded with a screenshot. The first question was asked more than once in each assistant, because answers change between runs.
| # | Assistant | Question | Companies | You | Sources it cited |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | ChatGPT | best pool cleaning service in Sanford FL | 4 | no | not shown |
| 2 | ChatGPT | best pool cleaning service in Sanford FL | 5 | no | HomeAdvisor, Birdeye, Angi |
| 3 | ChatGPT | who should I hire for weekly pool cleaning in Sanford FL | 3 | no | not shown |
| 4 | ChatGPT | affordable pool cleaning near Sanford FL | 4 | no | not shown |
| 5 | ChatGPT | my pool turned green who can fix it in Sanford FL | 4 | no | not shown |
| 6 | ChatGPT | reliable pool company in Sanford FL with good reviews | 5 | no | not shown |
| 7 | Google AI Mode | best pool cleaning service in Sanford FL | 5 | no | Google profiles |
| 8 | Google AI Mode | best pool cleaning service in Sanford FL | 4 | no | Google profiles, Thumbtack, a website |
| 9 | Google AI Mode | who should I hire for weekly pool cleaning in Sanford FL | 5 | no | Google profiles |
| 10 | Google AI Mode | affordable pool cleaning near Sanford FL | 5 | no | Google profiles |
| 11 | Google AI Mode | my pool turned green who can fix it in Sanford FL | 5 | yes | Google profiles |
| 12 | Google AI Mode | reliable pool company in Sanford FL with good reviews | 5 | no | Google profiles |
| 13 | Perplexity | best pool cleaning service in Sanford FL | 5 | no | Two competitors' websites, BBB |
| 14 | Perplexity | best pool cleaning service in Sanford FL | 5 | no | BBB, two competitors' websites |
| 15 | Perplexity | best pool cleaning service in Sanford FL | 1 | no | Angi |
How the check was done
Every question was typed the way a customer would, into each assistant, signed out, and the full answer was saved with a screenshot. A business counts as named only when it appears in the answer text itself, not just on a map card next to it.
Answers vary by day and by location. That's why the 30-day re-check uses exactly the same questions in the same assistants, so the before and after can be compared fairly.
The question set, with the town filled in:
- best pool cleaning service in Sanford FL
- who should I hire for weekly pool cleaning in Sanford FL
- best pool service company in Sanford FL
- affordable pool cleaning near Sanford FL
- my pool turned green who can fix it in Sanford FL
- pool pump repair near Sanford FL
- reliable pool company in Sanford FL with good reviews
- how much does weekly pool service cost in Sanford FL and who should I use
This report used five of the eight. A full check runs all eight for each town you serve. Other businesses get their own set, for example “where should I eat tonight in…” for a restaurant or “who does the best haircut in…” for a salon.
Want this for your business?
Send your business name and the towns you serve. The check is free and you'll get it within three working days.
Or email gordey@shortlistry.com
- Fixing it
- The fix-up covers every finding above (website, Google profile, listings and reviews), for $250–400, with a 30-day re-check. See prices.